Insurance Advisory Firms Embrace Data-Driven Insights, Self-Service, and Unbiased Expertise in 2025

As M&A drives evolution, firms are leveraging advanced technologies, developing comprehensive data platforms, and maintaining their role as unbiased experts to provide more valuable and accessible insights to their clients in the rapidly transforming insurance sector.

(Image credit: Headway/Unsplash.)

Insurance Advisory Firms Embrace Data-Driven Insights, Self-Service, and Unbiased Expertise in 2025

The insurance advisory and analyst landscape is undergoing significant transformation in 2025, with firms focusing on three major trends: data-driven insights, self-service platforms, and unbiased expertise. These changes are occurring against a backdrop of industry consolidation and technological advancement.

M&A-Driven Evolution

As insurance companies face increasingly complex challenges in a rapidly changing market, advisory firms are positioning themselves as indispensable partners. They are leveraging cutting-edge technologies and large data resources to provide more comprehensive and actionable insights. This evolution is not just about keeping pace with change; it’s about anticipating future needs and equipping insurers with the tools and knowledge to thrive in an increasingly digital and data-driven environment.

The advisory landscape is also changing due to mergers and acquisitions. In 2022, Strategy Meets Action was acquired by ReSource Pro (New York, N.Y.), a business process outsourcer, and in 2023 Novarica and Aite Group combined to become Datos Insights (Boston, Mass.). Datos Insights also includes RBR Data Services, whose research includes data related to cards and payments. Celent (Boston, Mass.) was recently acquired by GlobalData PLC (London, England), a multi-industry data analytics and consulting company.

These business moves underscore the growing importance of combining deep industry expertise with advanced data analytics capabilities. Advisory firms are no longer just repositories of industry knowledge; they are becoming sophisticated data analysis companies, capable of uncovering trends and insights that might otherwise remain hidden.

The transformation of the insurance advisory sector is part of a broader trend of digital transformation across the insurance industry. As insurers grapple with emerging technologies, changing customer expectations, and new risk landscapes, they are increasingly turning to advisory firms for guidance and support. In this context, the role of insurance advisory firms is evolving from traditional consultants to strategic partners, helping insurers navigate the complexities of the modern insurance landscape. The trends shaping the advisory sector in 2025 reflect this shift, emphasizing the need for more sophisticated, data-driven, and accessible insights to drive decision-making in an increasingly competitive and dynamic market.

Data-Driven Insights: Merging Expertise with Analytics

Advisory firms are increasingly combining deep industry knowledge with advanced data analytics to provide unique insights. Karlyn Carnahan, Head of North American Insurance at Celent, emphasizes this shift: “It’s finding those unique insights. If all you have is data, then an insurance carrier house has a lot of smart people who can analyze the data. If all you have is experience, then eventually you run out of that unique insight”.

Ronak Doshi, Partner at Everest Group (Dallas, Texas), notes the evolution of the traditional analyst model: “The traditional analyst model, which relies on industry experts with decades of experience to serve as analysts, is evolving in the age of artificial intelligence and platform-driven research. This evolution incorporates unique data assets, expertise, and technology to enable the publication of research at speed and scale”. 

Self-Service Platforms: Empowering Clients

A significant trend in the industry is the move towards self-service platforms, enabling insurance companies to access and interpret data independently. Carnahan explains, “We’ve been moving down that self-service path for a while with what we’ve been doing with the platform and allowing clients to gather their own data”.

This shift transforms how insurance companies interact with advisory services, reducing reliance on direct analyst consultations for basic information gathering. The trend is toward enabling clients to access data and insights more efficiently, while still relying on analysts for interpretation and strategic guidance.

Unbiased Expertise: A Valued Asset

The importance of unbiased expertise in the insurance advisory sector continues to grow. Martina Conlon, Executive Principal at Datos Insights, highlights this trend: “Insurers rely on the analyst community, not vendors, to get an unbiased view on emerging technology adoption, successes and failures”.

Analyst firms have long established themselves as trusted advisors for insurers facing decisions about expensive technology replacements and high-risk implementation projects. Analysts continue to provide advisory services in an environment of rapid technology change and increasing options for insurance technology solutions.

Industry Consolidation and Global Delivery Models

Doshi points out the ongoing consolidation in the sector: “The BFSI industry analyst sector has experienced consolidation in recent years, with notable events including the establishment of Datos Insights. The acquisition of Celent continues this trend”.

To address talent gaps and reduce costs, firms are developing global delivery models. Doshi explains, “Everest Group has established a robust analyst training program that facilitates global talent acquisition and trains individuals to combine strong analyst and consulting mindsets”.

As these trends converge, the insurance advisory landscape is evolving to meet the changing needs of the industry. Firms are leveraging advanced technologies, developing comprehensive data platforms, and maintaining their role as unbiased experts to provide more valuable and accessible insights to their clients in the rapidly transforming insurance sector.

New Beginnings: Insurance Innovation 2025

Tom Benton // Tom Benton is a recognized thought leader in the insurance industry, with over 20 years of experience driving IT strategy and innovation. As a former insurance CIO and consultant, Tom has worked with insurers and technology providers to develop and implement strategic plans that improve customer experience, reduce risks, and enhance operational efficiency. He leverages his expertise in IT capability assessment, transformation preparedness, and solution provider evaluation to help organizations align their technology strategies with emerging industry needs and trends. Tom was most recently a Partner at ReSource Pro, formerly known as Strategy Meets Action. Tom also served as Vice President of Research and Consulting at Novarica and as Chief Information Officer at Navy Mutual, as well as CIO and CTO for major nonprofit organizations in Washington, DC. Tom holds a master's degree from MIT and a bachelor's degree from Cornell University, and he has contributed to numerous industry reports, publications, and webinars. His passion lies in helping insurers and insuretechs embrace innovative solutions for long-term success in a rapidly evolving market.

Comment (1)

  1. The problem is that insurance organizations are no longer willing to pay $30k/annually for “unbiased opinions” about insurtechs or vendors to potentially use. Insurance executives today are HAPPY to get biased opinions and real world metrics from friends in the industry who are willing to share experiences with insurtechs/vendors “in the wild.” Personal reference goes further than anything in the insurance industry.

Leave a Comment

(required)